Darklight Phoenix lost $91.41 in a week, and new sets drove Magic's drops
Mr. Spock, Science Officer fell 77.7% in the days after Star Trek launched. Three Mystery Booster Commander Edition cards were among the six big gains.
From November 10 to November 17, 1,070 of the 2,074 Magic: The Gathering cards that trade often got cheaper, and 964 got more expensive. The median card moved just −0.1%, so for most of the market it was a quiet week. Twelve cards moved 10% or more: six fell and six rose.
The largest move in dollars came from a new set, and so did most of the drops.
Darklight Phoenix lost $91.41
Darklight Phoenix (Borderless) (Facet Foil) (0453) from Reality Fracture went from $365.93 to $274.52, a drop of 25.0%. On November 17 the cheapest copy for sale was $242.74, well under the market price, so sellers are asking less than recent sales suggest.
Reality Fracture came out October 2. A second card from the set, the foil The Theorist, Jace Beleren (Borderless) (0443), lost 22.2% and ended the week at $44.44.
Five of six big drops came from recent sets
Two of the drops are from Reality Fracture and two from Star Trek, which was released November 13. The fifth is The Arkenstone (Showcase) in foil from The Hobbit (August 14), down 22.1% to $21.48.
The sharpest fall was in Star Trek. The foil Mr. Spock, Science Officer (Borderless) dropped from $107.98 to $24.04, a loss of $83.94, or 77.7%. Launch prices are set before boxes are opened at scale, and they often move once supply arrives.
Stomping Ground (Showcase) (Surge Foil), also from Star Trek, lost 23.9% to $39.87. The only older card among the big drops is Nicol Bolas, Dragon-God from War of the Spark (2019), down 31.6% to $21.89.
Deep Space 9 and Mystery Booster led the gains
Deep Space 9 (Extended Art) rose 67.0%, from $23.40 to $39.08, and its foil version gained 48.5%, to $52.31. Both have cheapest listings above the market price: $58.00 and $79.99.
Mystery Booster Commander Edition supplied three of the six gains. Maular, the Next Evolution rose 42.9% to $35.44, Seluma, Light of Aysen 32.0% to $38.77, and Homer, the Hermit 26.3% to $48.02. Greymond, Avacyn's Stalwart from The List Reprints added 18.5%, to $30.49.
All twelve big moves
| Card | Set | Nov 10 | Nov 17 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mr. Spock, Science Officer (Borderless) · foil | Star Trek | $107.98 | $24.04 | −77.7% |
| Nicol Bolas, Dragon-God | War of the Spark | $31.98 | $21.89 | −31.6% |
| Darklight Phoenix (Borderless) (Facet Foil) (0453) | Reality Fracture | $365.93 | $274.52 | −25.0% |
| Stomping Ground (Showcase) (Surge Foil) | Star Trek | $52.37 | $39.87 | −23.9% |
| The Theorist, Jace Beleren (Borderless) (0443) · foil | Reality Fracture | $57.10 | $44.44 | −22.2% |
| The Arkenstone (Showcase) · foil | The Hobbit | $27.56 | $21.48 | −22.1% |
| Deep Space 9 (Extended Art) | Star Trek | $23.40 | $39.08 | +67.0% |
| Deep Space 9 (Extended Art) · foil | Star Trek | $35.22 | $52.31 | +48.5% |
| Maular, the Next Evolution | Mystery Booster Commander Edition | $24.80 | $35.44 | +42.9% |
| Seluma, Light of Aysen | Mystery Booster Commander Edition | $29.38 | $38.77 | +32.0% |
| Homer, the Hermit | Mystery Booster Commander Edition | $38.01 | $48.02 | +26.3% |
| Greymond, Avacyn's Stalwart | The List Reprints | $25.72 | $30.49 | +18.5% |
New sets set the tone
Twelve big moves out of 2,074 cards is a small slice, and the median barely budged. The pattern sat at the edges: the biggest dollar move was a $274.52 Reality Fracture card, and five of the six big drops came from sets released in the last four months. For more on that set, see our look at Reality Fracture's prices four weeks after launch. Every Magic card and its full price history is on the Magic: The Gathering page.