- tcgrate
- Games
- Magic: The Gathering
- Cards
- Pick Your Poison
Magic: The Gathering · 6 printings · 6 priced
Pick Your Poison card prices
Pick Your Poison card prices across all 6 printings we track, from $0.31 to $6.15 — the version you hold decides the value, not the name.
Price range · Oct 18, 2026
$0.31 – $6.15
most expensive: Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive #185
Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical A… · #185$6.15
Mystery Booster: Convention Editi…$0.70
Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical A… · #120$0.46
Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical A… · #55$0.39
Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive · most expensive printing1 year
$5.79$8.09$10.39$12.68
$6.15Apr 17Jun 17Aug 17Oct 18
TCGplayer market price · via tcgcsvtcgrate.com
Every printing
most expensive first
−0.5% 7d
Pick Your Poison (JP Alternate Art) (Silver Scroll Foil)
$6.15
0.0% 7d
Pick Your Poison
$0.70
−4.2% 7d
Pick Your Poison (JP Alternate Art)
$0.46
−4.9% 7d
Pick Your Poison
$0.39
+9.7% 7d
Pick Your Poison
$0.34
| Printing | Market | 7d | 30 days | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 |
Pick Your Poison (JP Alternate Art) (Silver Scroll Foil)Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive · #185 · U | $6.15 | −0.5% | |
 |
Pick Your PoisonMystery Booster: Convention Edition Exclusives · S | $0.70 | 0.0% | |
 |
Pick Your Poison (JP Alternate Art)Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive · #120 · U | $0.46 | −4.2% | |
 |
Pick Your PoisonSecrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive · #55 · U | $0.39 | −4.9% | |
 |
Pick Your PoisonMurders at Karlov Manor · #170 · C | $0.34 | +9.7% | |
 |
Pick Your Poison (No PW Symbol)Mystery Booster: Convention Edition Exclusives · S | $0.31 | 0.0% |
Why Pick Your Poison has 6 prices
Each printing is a different physical card — a different set, number, often a different frame or foil treatment — and the market prices them separately. The range above runs from the cheapest priced printing to the most expensive one; the chart follows the most expensive. Open any row to see that printing's own history, every foil variant, and where it costs less.