tcgrate
  1. tcgrate
  2. Games
  3. Magic: The Gathering
  4. Cards
  5. Massacre

Magic: The Gathering · 4 printings · 4 priced

Massacre card prices

Massacre card prices across all 4 printings we track, from $0.37 to $56.83 — the version you hold decides the value, not the name.

Price range · Oct 18, 2026
$0.37 – $56.83
most expensive: Nemesis #58
Nemesis · #58$56.83
Secret Lair Drop Series · #9991$5.46
Secret Lair Drop Series · #9991$2.71
The List Reprints · #58/143$0.37
All printings Price guide Top cards Game
Nemesis · most expensive printing1 year
$25.70$37.05$48.41$59.77
$56.83
Oct 2025Feb 2026Jun 2026Oct 2026
TCGplayer market price · via tcgcsvtcgrate.com
Printings
4
Priced
4
Cheapest
$0.37
Most expensive
$56.83

Every printing

most expensive first
Massacre (58), Nemesis — Magic card price +15.0% 7d Massacre Nemesis · #58 $56.83 mAsSaCRe (9991), Secret Lair Drop Series — Magic card price −0.6% 7d mAsSaCRe Secret Lair Drop Series · #9991 $5.46 mAsSaCRe (Rainbow Foil) (9991), Secret Lair Drop Series — Magic card price 0.0% 7d mAsSaCRe (Rainbow Foil) Secret Lair Drop Series · #9991 $2.71 Massacre (58/143), The List Reprints — Magic card price +5.7% 7d Massacre The List Reprints · #58/143 $0.37
PrintingReleasedMarket7d30d1y30 days
Massacre (58), Nemesis — Magic card price MassacreNemesis · #58 · U Feb 14, 2000 $56.83 +15.0% +18.0% +91.0%
mAsSaCRe (9991), Secret Lair Drop Series — Magic card price mAsSaCReSecret Lair Drop Series · #9991 · R — $5.46 −0.6% +7.5% +35.8%
mAsSaCRe (Rainbow Foil) (9991), Secret Lair Drop Series — Magic card price mAsSaCRe (Rainbow Foil)Secret Lair Drop Series · #9991 · R — $2.71 0.0% −1.5% +13.9%
Massacre (58/143), The List Reprints — Magic card price MassacreThe List Reprints · #58/143 · U — $0.37 +5.7% +8.8% −7.5%

Why Massacre has 4 prices

Each printing is a different physical card — a different set, number, often a different frame or foil treatment — and the market prices them separately. The range above runs from the cheapest priced printing to the most expensive one; the chart follows the most expensive. Open any row to see that printing's own history, every foil variant, and where it costs less.